Alfred Papa Darkwah, who represents Superintendent George Asare, stated that the report’s content differs significantly from what was aired on live TV and what transpired behind closed doors.

“A lot of things came up, but the committee decided to pick and choose which evidence to include in their report. That is somewhat disturbing,” he told Evans Mensah on PM Express on Monday.

He explained that the hearings were inquisitorial, not adversarial. In an inquisitorial system, committee members are actively involved, acting both as judges and prosecutors.

“They owe it to themselves to conduct a detailed investigation into all matters that transpired. Issues like extrajudicial killings and unlawful promotions were all contained in the tape. These were not external matters, so there was no need to bring witnesses to validate their authenticity.”

Darkwah disagreed with the claim that his client failed to provide evidence when given the opportunity by the Committee.

“He did not fail. The Committee failed to inform us why this individual failed. We provided evidence,” he insisted.

According to him, he brought in witnesses to support what his clients had been telling the Committee but it came to a question of “how can witnesses also call in witnesses? And was the mistake that they made because as I said, it was an inquisitorial system.”

“I brought in witness statements which were presented to the committee. The least they could have done was look through the statements and see if they were not relevant, nothing of that sort happened. They kept mute on that. And rather conveniently concluded that these individuals failed to provide evidence.”

His comment comes after the majority of Parliamentary Committee members who investigated the leaked tape saga recommended sanctions for the three officers involved.

Chaired by Abuakwa South lawmaker Samuel Atta Akyea, these members found that officers COP Alex George Mensah, Supt. George Lysander Asare, and Supt. Emmanuel Eric Gyedi had misconducted themselves, which constitutes a major offence under Police regulations.

They recommended that these officers be sanctioned according to the Police disciplinary procedure.

They requested that the House communicate its findings to the President, in line with Section 19 of the Police Service Act, 1970 (Act 350), to ensure appropriate sanctions are imposed.

“The House should communicate its findings to the President pursuant to Section 19 of the Police Service Act, 1970 (Act 350) which vests disciplinary powers in the President, to determine the appropriate sanctions for COP George Alex Mensah, Supt George Lysander Asare and Supt Eric Emmanuel Gyebi who appear to have misconducted themselves professionally by breaching among others the following:  Section 17(d) of the Police Service Act, 1970 (Act 350) which states that:

“It shall be misconduct for a police officer to engage in any activity outside his official duties which is likely to involve him in political controversy or to lead to his taking improper advantage of his position in the Police Service.

“Regulation 82(1) (c) of the Police Service Regulations, 2012 (C.I 76) which states that: “It is a major offence for an officer to engage in an activity outside official duties which is likely to “Involve the officer in political controversy or lead to the officer taking improper advantage of that officer’s position in the service,” the report said.

ALSO READ:

• Leaked IGP Tape: He set me up to keep his job – COP George…

• IGP leaked tape: Supt. Asare, Supt. Gyebi caught lying, committee cites them for contempt

The committee chaired by Abuakwa South MP, Samuel Atta Akyea was tasked to investigate the leaked audio in which some senior officers were heard in a conversation with former Northern Regional Chairman of the NPP Chief Bugri Naabu plotting the removal of IGP Dampare by the committee that investigated the leaked tape in which some senior officers were alleged to be plotting his removal.

The officers had alleged that, Dr Dampare’s strictness could adversely affect the electoral prospects of the New Patriotic Party(NPP) in future elections.

They also accused him of indiscriminately arresting officers from sister security agencies.

However, the committee in its report has said it found no evidence to substantiate their claims, instead, stated the actions of the senior officers poses danger to Ghana’s democracy.

“The conspiracy by COP Mensah, Supt. Asare and Supt. Gyebi to remove the IGP based purely on partisan considerations, could undermine free, fair, and transparent elections and, ultimately, the sanctity of Ghana’s democracy.

“COP Alex Mensah, Supt. Asare and Supt. Gyebi indeed conspired to cause the removal of the IGP and have him replaced with a loyalist of the NPP, and acting on that, resolved to meet the President to accomplish their goal,” portions of the report read.

Additionally, the committee pointed out that two of the officers lied and has referred them to the Privileges Committee.

“The Committee is of the view that Supt. Asare and Supt. Gyebi appeared to have acted in contempt of Parliament pursuant to Order 30 of the Standing Orders of Parliament (2000) as revised by Order 13 )1( of the Standing Orders of Parliament (2024). In this regard, the Committee is of the opinion that the matter be referred to the Privileges Committee for appropriate action.”

ALSO READ:

• Supt Asare drags another police officer into IGP leaked tape saga

• IGP leaked tape: Supt. Asare, Supt. Gyebi caught lying, committee cites them for contempt